An Uncommon Cape

Researching the Histories and Mysteries of a Property

By Eleanor Phillips Brackbill

Subjects: Architectural History/architecture, New York/regional, History
Series: Excelsior Editions
Imprint: Excelsior Editions
Hardcover : 9781438443072, 259 pages, September 2012

Alternative formats available from:

Table of contents

List of Illustrations
Part I: Mysteries of the House
1. Something Like a Sears House
2. The House Finds a Home
3. The Cape Cod House: Why So Common, Why So Popular?
Part II: Thirty-Two Owners in 350 Years: A Focus on Four
4. Wappaquewam: Siwanoy Sakima
5. Caleb Heathcote: Manor Lord
6. Isaac Gedney Jr.: The Neutral Ground
7. Louis Block and Harry Rich Mooney: From Farm Subdivision
Part III: Mysteries of the Land
8. In New York or In Connecticut?
9. Moon Over Mamroneck: When and Where?
10. Monkey Business and More: The Possibilities
Epilogue: Kernels of Truth
Sidebar Notes
Selected Bibliography

Three mysteries precipitate an investigation into an otherwise ordinary suburban property, revealing a past inextricably woven into four centuries of American history.


When Eleanor Phillips Brackbill bought her suburban Westchester house in 2000, three mysteries came with it. First, from the former owner, came the information that the 1930s house was "a Sears house or something like that." Thrilled to think it might be a Sears, Roebuck & Co. mail-order house, Brackbill was determined to find evidence to prove it. She found instead a house pedigree of a different sort.

Second, and even more provocative, was the discovery of several iron stakes protruding from the property's enormous granite outcropping, bigger in square footage than the house itself. When queried about them, the former owner told her, "Someone a long time ago kept monkeys there, chained to the stakes." Monkeys? Was this some kind of suburban legend?

A third mystery came to light at closing, when a building inspector's letter contained a reference to the house having had, at one time, a different address. Why would the house have had another address? Her curiosity aroused, and intent upon finding the facts, Brackbill gradually peeled back layers of history, allowing the house and the land to tell their stories, and uncovering a past inextricably woven into four centuries of American history. At the same time, she found thirty-two owners, across 350 years, who had just one thing in common: ownership of a particular parcel of land.

An Uncommon Cape not only tells the story of an eight-year odyssey of fact-finding and speculation but also answers the broader question: "What came before?" and, through material presented in twenty-two sidebars, offers readers insights and guidelines on how to find the stories behind their own homes.

Eleanor Phillips Brackbill is former Curator of Education at the Neuberger Museum of Art, Purchase College–SUNY.


"A detective story set in her own backyard, Eleanor Phillips Brackbill's book shows the rich stories even our own homes can tell us if we take the time to hear them. What to most looks like a common residential Cape-style home in a suburban neighborhood can tell us more about ourselves as New Yorkers than anything we learned about in school. This book is a testament to the value of historic preservation and an appreciation of all that is our past, including our victories, our failures, and our faults." — Jay A. DiLorenzo, President, Preservation League of New York

"Eleanor Phillips Brackbill's in-depth genealogy/biography of the house in which she lives and the land on which it sets is a brilliantly written model of superb research and storytelling. It recognizes the opportunity, perhaps the responsibility, to learn and record and pass along to future generations all that can be found out about the history of property for which we are transient stewards. Her Uncommon Cape is a perfect vehicle for bringing back to life four centuries of enthralling regional (and American) history while allowing many interrelated, but yet unsolved, mysteries to live on. Brackbill ably succeeds in convincing us that the past is not even past!" — Charles Duell, President, Middleton Place Foundation and author of Middleton Place: A Phoenix Still Rising

"Home ownership has become, for better and for worse, a profound part of contemporary American identity. Eleanor Phillips Brackbill delves into this terrain—quite literally—by piecing together the genealogy of her home, which she reconstructs through diligent archival detective work (and even the occasional late-night trek through the woods). As such, her study is as much about the craft of historical inquiry as it is about the vicissitudes of a particular chunk of real estate. With sidebars that offer research tips placed throughout the text, the book will be a useful guide for those interested in pursuing their own historical investigations." — Michael Lobel, author of James Rosenquist: Pop Art, Politics, and History in the 1960s

"A page-turning read. I got totally caught up in the history of a county, a country, and a sturdy little house. Brackbill's meticulous research fascinates and will cause me to dig into my own house's story—its moves, its occupants, and its alterations." — Lucy Hedrick, author and publishing coach